What the notice is
"You received this notice because you have an unpaid balance due." That is the IRS's whole explanation of a CP161. Businesses that file their own returns commonly receive this form of the balance-due letter, and it comes with two things a CP14 does not emphasize: a printed list of the payments the IRS applied to your account, and a short window to say the IRS got it wrong.
The IRS tells you to "check the list of payments we applied to your account to see if we applied all the payments you made." That sentence is the entire bookkeeping assignment.
The deadline
Two clocks run at once.
Ten days to dispute. "Contact us within 10 days of the date of your notice if you think we made a mistake." The IRS asks you to have documentation ready, and names cancelled checks and an amended return as examples.
The payment due date on the notice. "Interest will continue to increase on the unpaid balance after the payment due date." The IRS says you will receive a late-payment or failure-to-deposit penalty depending on what you owe. The failure-to-pay penalty is 0.5% of the unpaid tax for each month or part of a month, up to 25%, and the IRS charges interest on penalties. A payment plan can be requested if the full amount is not possible.
Ten days is not enough time to rebuild a year of payments from scratch. It is enough time to compare two lists that already exist.
What your books must show
1. Your payment list, in the same shape as the IRS's. The notice prints the payments the IRS applied: date, amount, and the period each was credited to. Your books need the same three columns for every payment you made toward that tax and that year, plus the confirmation number and the bank transaction that funded it. Laying the two lists side by side is how you find the payment the IRS did not apply, or applied somewhere else.
2. Which taxpayer number each payment was made under. A business payment made under an owner's personal number, or a payment made under an old entity's number after a change, lands on a different account. The ledger records the number used.
3. Which period each payment was meant for. Estimated payments and deposits are period-specific. The IRS notes that corporations generally make estimated payments if they expect to owe $500 or more, and that a payment due on a weekend or legal holiday is on time if made the next business day. A payment intended for one quarter and credited to another shows up on a CP161 as a shortfall in the first and an overpayment in the second.
4. Deposits, if the balance is employment tax. The notice can also follow a missed or late deposit. If your business runs payroll through a provider, the provider's deposit confirmations belong in the same ledger as your income-tax payments, so one list answers either kind of balance.
5. The return the balance comes from. The return, and the payments it claimed, so the gap is traceable to a specific claimed payment rather than a general disagreement.
The records your accountant will ask for
- The CP161 notice, including the payment list the IRS printed.
- Your own payment ledger with confirmations and bank matches.
- Bank statements covering the payment dates.
- The return for the period on the notice.
- Payroll deposit confirmations from your provider, if the balance relates to employment tax.
- Any prior IRS correspondence about the same period.
Your accountant makes the call on whether the IRS made a mistake and handles the contact. Your job inside ten days is to hand over the two lists.
Prosper prepares records for your accountant. This is not tax advice.