What the notice is
The IRS is direct about this one: "We sent you this notice because you owe money on unpaid taxes." A CP14 is the first balance-due letter. It states an amount, a due date, and how to pay.
For a first-time owner the surprise is rarely the tax. It is that the IRS's number and the number on the return do not agree, and the gap is almost always a payment problem, not a return problem:
- An estimated payment was planned but never sent.
- A payment was sent but applied to the wrong tax year.
- A payment was made under a personal identification number when the return was filed under the business's, or the reverse.
- The return claimed a payment that a payroll or platform withholding never actually made.
All of those are answerable from records. None of them are answerable from memory.
The deadline
"Pay the amount you owe by the due date on the notice." After that date, the IRS says, "interest accrues on the unpaid amount," and a late-payment penalty applies if the full amount is not paid.
The failure-to-pay penalty is 0.5% of the unpaid taxes for each month or part of a month, capped at 25%. It changes in two directions: down to 0.25% per month for individuals who filed on time and have an approved payment plan, and up to 1% per month if the tax is not paid within 10 days of a notice of intent to levy. The IRS also charges interest on penalties. A payment plan can be requested online if the full amount is not possible.
What your books must show
1. An estimated-payment ledger. One line per payment: the date sent, the amount, the method, the confirmation number, the taxpayer identification number it was made under, and the tax year and quarter it was meant for. The IRS says individuals generally have to make estimated payments if they expect to owe $1,000 or more when the return is filed, and corporations if they expect to owe $500 or more. If you were supposed to be making them, the ledger is the proof that you did.
2. The bank side of every payment. Each ledger line matched to the bank transaction that funded it. A payment that exists in the ledger and not in the bank never happened.
3. What the return assumed. The payments and credits the return claimed, so your accountant can lay the ledger next to the return and see which claimed payment the IRS did not find.
4. Year boundaries. Estimated payments fall in four payment periods, and the last one for a year is paid in the following calendar year. The IRS notes that a payment due on a weekend or legal holiday is on time if made the next business day. Payments near a year boundary are the ones most often applied to the wrong year, so date and intended year both need to be recorded.
5. Withholding, if any. If tax was withheld by a payroll provider or a platform, the year-end forms that show it.
The records your accountant will ask for
- The CP14 notice, all pages.
- The return the notice refers to.
- The estimated-payment ledger with confirmations.
- Bank statements showing each payment clearing.
- Any IRS payment confirmations or account transcripts you have.
- Year-end withholding forms.
If a payment was misapplied, your accountant will handle the conversation with the IRS. The IRS page says to have paperwork such as cancelled checks ready; the ledger is that paperwork in one place.
Prosper prepares records for your accountant. This is not tax advice.